Noise-Cancelling Showdown: Headphones vs Earbuds. Which One Is the Best?

In a world constantly buzzing with sounds, finding a haven of auditory bliss can be a challenge. Whether it’s the clatter of a busy café, the chatter of a crowded train, or just the hum of your air conditioner, these ambient noises often interfere with you and the audio experience you crave. 

So, how do you dive into your favourite tunes, podcasts, or audiobooks without the intrusion of the external world? The answer lies in noise-cancelling devices: headphones and earbuds.  

Employing advanced Active Noise Cancellation (ANC) technology, these gadgets are engineered to minimise or block unwanted ambient sounds, offering you an immersive audio realm.

In today’s piece, we’ll delve into a comparative analysis of both to help you discern which one aligns with your auditory desires and lifestyle. 

Today’s Focus of Attention is reader-supported. We sometimes include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission.

These are electronic devices, wired or Bluetooth, that cover your ears and block out external noises. They have built-in microphones that pick up ambient sounds and generate opposite waves to cancel them out. This way, you hear only what you want from your audio source. 

They can be either over- or on-ear, depending on how they fit on your head. 

“When I wear headphones, it’s like the whole world just disappears.”Conor Maynard

Over-ears offer better noise reduction than on-ears because they create a seal around your hearing area, blocking ambient disturbance more efficiently. 

Active Noise Cancellation (ANC) varies from model to model. Be sure to read reviews to see how well different headphones perform at reducing various noises.

Famous brands include Bowers & Wilkings, Sennheiser, Skullcandy, Beats, Sony, Apple, Bose, Audio Technica, and JBL. 

Here’s a sample of popular NC headphones on the market. Of course, many other great options are available, so it’s important to do your homework and find the pair that meets your needs and budget. 

“Beats succeeded because, as music lovers, we knew oscilloscopes don’t buy headphones – people do.” Jimmy Lovine

These are devices that fit into your ear canal and prevent external interference. They use the same technology as the headphones. But, unlike headphones, earbuds do not cover your ears. They only partially block out the noises and rely more on ANC science to reduce them. 

They come in two forms: in-ear and true wireless. 

In-ear models have a wire connecting both earpieces, while true wireless versions are completely cordless. Similar to headphones, noise cancellation varies from model to model.

The universe of brands includes Bose, Apple AirPods, Sony, Beat, Jabra, and Sennheiser. Here’s a glimpse of popular NC earphones on the market:  

You need to consider factors such as price, comfort, sound quality, battery life, and portability. Let’s look at each aspect of both gadgets: 

In general, noise-cancelling headphones are more expensive than earbuds if you want world-class ones. 

A decent pair of NC headphones sells for anywhere from $150 to $600, while reputable earphones are between $50 and $300. Of course, the price varies based on the brand, model, features, and design.  

Here’s a comparison table:

Since these gadgets will rest on your ears or nestle within them for hours, consider comfort an indispensable aspect. 

Headphones envelop your ears in padded cushions, distribute weight across your head, and minimise pressure. Some come with adjustable headbands and rotating earcups to find the perfect match. For those with glasses, certain headphone designs adapt to the frames, ensuring a comfortable fit. 

Lightweight and less visible, earbuds sit within the hearing canal or rest on the outer ear, making them a breeze to wear over extended periods. However, the right width is paramount to prevent them from slipping out and to achieve the desired level of noise cancellation.

Dozens of models come with interchangeable ear tips of varying sizes to adjust to different shapes. 

Comfort is a personal journey. Try on several kinds before making a purchase and check as many reviews as possible from those who’ve taken the plunge. 

The essence of a pair of headphones or earbuds lies in their ability to deliver crisp, clear, and vibrant symphonies while blocking out unwanted noise. 

Headphones have larger drivers, the components responsible for converting electrical signals into audible content. This advantage often translates to a richer bass response and a wider soundstage, allowing you to discern individual instruments and vocals with clarity. 

The over-ear design creates a secluded acoustic environment, taking music to the next level and enhancing noise cancellation. 

“Without music, life would be a mistake.” Friedrich Nietzsche

Earbuds, because of their size, might emphasise the mids and highs, lacking the deep bass and wide soundstage of headphones.

Let’s not forget that audio quality also plays an important role. High-resolution files paired with well-engineered noise-cancelling devices elevate your listening experience to a concert-like level. 

Sound excellence is subjective, and it depends on the genre you love. Some crave the bass headphones give, while others appreciate the highs of earbuds. So, test both with your favourite songs to determine which one aligns with your musical taste. 

Both gadgets, if wireless, need power to energise their ANC technology. Some batteries last longer, depending on the type, capacity, usage, and charging time of the device. 

Noise-cancelling headphones operate for 20 to 60 hours on a single charge, while a common pair of earbuds ranges from 5 to 7 hours. As usual, these numbers may vary according to the brand, model, features, and design. 

Here’s a comparison table:

In today’s on-the-go lifestyle, mobility is a significant point when choosing between headphones or earbuds. How easy they are to carry, store, and wear on the move might impact your overall user experience. 

Imagine you’re commuting to work and the train is crowded. With earphones, you pop them in and get lost in your favourite podcast. On a long-haul flight, however, you might go for headphones to immerse yourself in a movie or music album. 

Your lifestyle and daily routine play a pivotal role in determining your choice. 

Although headphones offer an immersive sound experience, their larger size poses a challenge for those in motion. They need more space in your bag, and carrying them when not in use can be a bit of a bind. However, many models come with foldable designs and small cases, making them easy to pack and transport.

On the flip side, earbuds are the epitome of portability. Their compact, lightweight design makes them easy to carry around, slip into your pocket, or store in a little compartment in your bag. The absence of a headband also means they won’t mess up your hairstyle or become a nuisance during physical activities like jogging or working out. 

So, should you get noise-cancelling headphones or earbuds? That decision is based on your preferences and needs. Both have their pros and cons; thus, weigh them before deciding. 

If you’re looking for a richer and fuller experience, sound quality, battery life, blocking most of the noise, and a warm embrace, headphones are the ones. But they are way more expensive, bulkier, and heavier than earphones. 

Earbuds may be better if you are after cost, portability, and discretion. Take them with you everywhere and use them in different situations. But you could sacrifice audio quality, battery life, and comfort. 

Anyhow, try both and figure out which one suits your preferences. 

We hope you have found this information useful. Please leave your comments in the section below! We’d love to hear from you.